The Peter Shields Inn (PSI) is our favorite restaurant in Cape May. The food is always amazing and the staff and service are a perfect complement. An added bonus is that PSI is a BYOB. In case you forget, they offer the Cape May Winery wines which are really good. PSI is a beautiful historic location with great views and ambiance.
LOCATION: .7 mile
FAVORITE DISHES: Apps: Tuna Tartar, Cape May Salts Oysters, Beet Salad. Entrees: Hanger Steak, Duck, Salmon, Tilefish Dessert: Crème Brulee, Chocolate Lava Cake
TIPS: When you go to PSI ask for Peter or Christoff for servers. Tell them the Wilhelm’s sent you! Also the house made hand scrubs in the restrooms are amazing.